Resistors Placed Before or After A SS Rectifier
- Hi-Fi-Mogul
- Anchor Member
- Posts: 1365
- Joined: Sat Jul 10, 2021 1:53 am
- Contact:
Resistors Placed Before or After A SS Rectifier
This is one of my questions that seem to pop up out of
no where and I wanted to ask before the mental file closes up.
With tube amplifiers using a solid state rectifier, I see that
a resistor may be placed before the rectifier or after it.
Can someone explain what the different designs are
intended to do ?
Are both uses to drop voltage for a particular
reason in the circuit design ?
Thanks !
no where and I wanted to ask before the mental file closes up.
With tube amplifiers using a solid state rectifier, I see that
a resistor may be placed before the rectifier or after it.
Can someone explain what the different designs are
intended to do ?
Are both uses to drop voltage for a particular
reason in the circuit design ?
Thanks !
Hi-Fi-Mogul
- TC Chris
- Anchor Member
- Posts: 3778
- Joined: Tue Jul 13, 2021 3:50 am
- Location: Traverse City, MI
- Contact:
Re: Resistors Placed Before or After A SS Rectifier
I'll offer an idea, but always remember that my electrical engineering knowledge is very thin.
As long as the resistor is before the filter capacitors, it will drop voltage and also limit the inrush (charging) current.
Chris Campbell
As long as the resistor is before the filter capacitors, it will drop voltage and also limit the inrush (charging) current.
Chris Campbell
Re: Resistors Placed Before or After A SS Rectifier
Doesn't matter if the current limiting resistor is before or after the solid state diode. As a matter of practice, I like to put it BEFORE the diode. As stated above, as long as it is before the "load"--the capacitor(s) and actual circuitry.
One thing to be mindful of in design or retrofitting is asking yourself "Is it possible for the "expected load" to some how "disconnect" itself from the circuit in a catastrophic failure? If it does, then the draw of the expected current won't be there, and you won't get the voltage drop at the capacitor(s) and the capacitor(s) could be damaged by too high of voltage.
In other words, if you used a 160 volt electrolytic cap as a filter and the voltage it sees never goes above 150 VDC thanks to the diode, the current limiting resistor and ulitmately the load, that's fine and dandy..... BUT, disconnect the load due to some issue, but power is still available, the capacitor could charge up to 170 VDC and be toast.
120 VAC X 1.414 (peak) = 169.68
So, if it were a design where this could happen, you'd want to use at least a 200 VDC rated capacitor as it would not be damaged by the sudden "peak" charging voltage from rectifying the incoming line voltage.
One thing to be mindful of in design or retrofitting is asking yourself "Is it possible for the "expected load" to some how "disconnect" itself from the circuit in a catastrophic failure? If it does, then the draw of the expected current won't be there, and you won't get the voltage drop at the capacitor(s) and the capacitor(s) could be damaged by too high of voltage.
In other words, if you used a 160 volt electrolytic cap as a filter and the voltage it sees never goes above 150 VDC thanks to the diode, the current limiting resistor and ulitmately the load, that's fine and dandy..... BUT, disconnect the load due to some issue, but power is still available, the capacitor could charge up to 170 VDC and be toast.
120 VAC X 1.414 (peak) = 169.68
So, if it were a design where this could happen, you'd want to use at least a 200 VDC rated capacitor as it would not be damaged by the sudden "peak" charging voltage from rectifying the incoming line voltage.
- Hi-Fi-Mogul
- Anchor Member
- Posts: 1365
- Joined: Sat Jul 10, 2021 1:53 am
- Contact:
Re: Resistors Placed Before or After A SS Rectifier
Thanks Dr. Radio and Chris.
That makes it very clear.
This particular string heater circuit had
a fusible 22 Ohm sand resistor placed
before the selenium rectifier.
The orignal 22 Ohm was way above in value, and I
found a Vishay made 22 Ohm fusible one to replace it.
I'm thinking this was a standard type design to allow
for the resistor to fail, if there was a significant short
in circuit ?
That makes it very clear.
This particular string heater circuit had
a fusible 22 Ohm sand resistor placed
before the selenium rectifier.
The orignal 22 Ohm was way above in value, and I
found a Vishay made 22 Ohm fusible one to replace it.
I'm thinking this was a standard type design to allow
for the resistor to fail, if there was a significant short
in circuit ?
Hi-Fi-Mogul
- TC Chris
- Anchor Member
- Posts: 3778
- Joined: Tue Jul 13, 2021 3:50 am
- Location: Traverse City, MI
- Contact:
Re: Resistors Placed Before or After A SS Rectifier
Like when the selenium rectifier met a smelly death? I've only had one exhibit that drama. I had a Zenith G-725 at my office and once when i stepped out for some chores the rectifier perished. It was right under the speaker cone so the cone burned up, and there was a great odor. The rest of the staff were alarmed....Hi-Fi-Mogul wrote: ↑Sat Dec 09, 2023 11:44 pm I'm thinking this was a standard type design to allow
for the resistor to fail, if there was a significant short
in circuit ?
Chris Campbell
Re: Resistors Placed Before or After A SS Rectifier
It's hard to say what the original manufacturer had in mind, but typically, there was a 2 part benefit with the resistor.Hi-Fi-Mogul wrote: ↑Sat Dec 09, 2023 11:44 pm Thanks Dr. Radio and Chris.
That makes it very clear.
This particular string heater circuit had
a fusible 22 Ohm sand resistor placed
before the selenium rectifier.
The orignal 22 Ohm was way above in value, and I
found a Vishay made 22 Ohm fusible one to replace it.
I'm thinking this was a standard type design to allow
for the resistor to fail, if there was a significant short
in circuit ?
1) It would "soften" turn-on surge before the filter capacitor were charged up and/or before tube heaters reached operating temperature. Both uncharged capacitors and cold tube heaters can cause a significant current in-rush when first turned on.
2) It would indeed allow some sort of protection (although some would argue how much by the time something gave up the ghost). It's a nice current limiting device since resistors are linear in their operation. More and more and more current will result in more and more and more of a voltage drop across the resistor until power is too much for the body of the resistor and it goes "poof" acting like a fuse.
Re: Resistors Placed Before or After A SS Rectifier
TC Chris wrote: ↑Sun Dec 10, 2023 3:49 am
Like when the selenium rectifier met a smelly death? I've only had one exhibit that drama. I had a Zenith G-725 at my office and once when i stepped out for some chores the rectifier perished. It was right under the speaker cone so the cone burned up, and there was a great odor. The rest of the staff were alarmed....
Chris Campbell
That had to be a rather awkward conversation after............
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot] and 4 guests
